SEO Results: How to Tell if your SEO strategy is Working in 2024

An authentic guide sharing professional insights on how to measure your SEO performance effectively in 2024, tailored for industries like e-commerce, SaaS, and consumer products.

Introduction

Throughout my career in SEO, I've learned that success isn't just about implementing strategies—it's about measuring the right metrics to validate those strategies. Focusing on key performance indicators (KPIs) specific to your industry can make all the difference. I'd like to share my insights on seven essential metrics that have helped me gauge and enhance SEO performance for e-commerce, SaaS, and consumer product businesses. Understanding why these metrics matter, what good and bad performance look like in your industry, and how to track and improve them has been crucial in driving results.

1. Conversions

Why This Metric Is Important

Conversions are the ultimate goal of SEO efforts—they represent the desired actions users take on your website. Whether it's making a purchase, signing up for a trial, or downloading an app, conversions indicate the effectiveness of your SEO in attracting qualified traffic that takes action.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• For E-commerce:
  • Good: A conversion rate between 2% to 5% is average, with top performers exceeding 5%. (Source)
  • Bad: Below 2% may indicate issues with user experience, product offerings, or targeting.
• For SaaS:
  • Good: Conversion rates for free trials or demos typically range from 5% to 10%. (Source)
  • Bad: Below 5% suggests that messaging or value propositions might not be resonating.
• For Consumer Products:
  • Good: For apps or platforms like Yelp or TikTok, a conversion rate (e.g., app downloads, sign-ups) of 20% to 30% from landing pages is considered good. (Source)
  • Bad: Below 15% may indicate issues with appeal, user trust, or call-to-action effectiveness.

How to Track and Improve

Use Google Analytics or your preferred analytics tool to set up conversion goals specific to your industry KPIs.

• Tracking: In Google Analytics 4, navigate to Configure > Events to set up and monitor conversion events. Refer to Google's guide for step-by-step instructions.
• Improving:
  • E-commerce: Optimize product pages with high-quality images, detailed descriptions, and customer reviews. Simplify the checkout process to reduce cart abandonment.
  • SaaS: Highlight unique value propositions, offer easy access to free trials or demos, and use persuasive CTAs.
  • Consumer Products: Enhance app store landing pages with compelling visuals and clear descriptions, optimize onboarding processes, and encourage user-generated content to build trust.

2. Organic Traffic

Why This Metric Is Important

Organic traffic measures how many users find your site through search engines. It's a vital indicator of your website's visibility and SEO effectiveness in attracting potential customers without paid advertising.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• Good: A steady increase in organic traffic month over month, adjusted for seasonal trends in your industry.
• Bad: Declining or flat organic traffic, which could signal problems with rankings, content relevance, or technical issues.

How to Track and Improve

Use Google Analytics to monitor organic traffic.

• Tracking: Navigate to Reports > Acquisition > Traffic Acquisition and filter by Session Default Channel Grouping = Organic Search. This will show you the organic traffic over time.
• Improving:
  • Content Strategy: Create valuable content tailored to your industry's audience needs, focusing on topics with high search demand.
  • Keyword Optimization: Use tools like Google Keyword Planner or Semrush to identify relevant keywords with substantial search volume.
  • Technical SEO: Ensure your site is crawlable and fast-loading. Tools like Google PageSpeed Insights can help identify areas for improvement.

3. Keyword Rankings

Why This Metric Is Important

Monitoring keyword rankings helps you understand your site's visibility for specific search terms that are important to your industry. High rankings drive more qualified traffic.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• Good: Ranking in the top 3 positions for high-intent keywords relevant to your industry.
• Bad: Rankings beyond the first page for primary keywords, limiting exposure to potential customers.

How to Track and Improve

Utilize keyword tracking tools to monitor your positions.

• Tracking: Tools like Semrush Position Tracking or Ahrefs Rank Tracker allow you to monitor your keyword rankings over time and against competitors.
• Improving:
  • E-commerce: Optimize product and category pages with targeted keywords, and enhance meta titles and descriptions.
  • SaaS: Develop in-depth content like case studies, whitepapers, and blog posts targeting industry-specific terms.
  • Consumer Products: Focus on content that answers user queries about your app or platform, optimize app store listings, and utilize ASO (App Store Optimization) techniques alongside traditional SEO.

4. Technical Health

Why This Metric Is Important

Technical health ensures that search engines can crawl and index your site efficiently. Technical issues can hinder your site's performance regardless of content quality.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• Good: A site audit score above 85%, indicating minimal technical issues.
• Bad: A score below 70%, suggesting significant technical problems that could affect rankings.

How to Track and Improve

Conduct regular site audits to identify and fix technical issues.

• Tracking: Use tools like Semrush Site Audit or Ahrefs Site Audit to get a comprehensive report on your site's technical health.
• Improving:
  • Fix Crawl Errors: Resolve broken links, 404 errors, and redirect issues.
  • Improve Site Speed: Compress images, leverage browser caching, and minimize CSS and JavaScript files. Use GTmetrix for detailed insights.
  • Mobile Optimization: Ensure your site is responsive. Google's Mobile-Friendly Test can help assess your site's mobile performance.

5. Backlinks

Why This Metric Is Important

Backlinks from reputable sites enhance your domain authority, signaling trust to search engines. They are crucial for improving rankings and driving referral traffic.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• Good: A steady growth of backlinks from high-authority, relevant websites in your industry.
• Bad: Backlinks from spammy or irrelevant sites, or a sudden drop in backlinks, which can harm your rankings.

How to Track and Improve

Monitor your backlink profile and work on acquiring quality links.

• Tracking: Use tools like Semrush Backlink Analytics or Ahrefs Backlink Checker to keep an eye on new and lost backlinks.
• Improving:
  • E-commerce: Partner with influencers or bloggers for product reviews and unboxings.
  • SaaS: Contribute guest posts to industry blogs and participate in webinars or podcasts.
  • Consumer Products: Collaborate with content creators, engage in PR campaigns, and encourage users to share your app or platform through social sharing features.
  • Disavow Toxic Links: Use Google Search Console to disavow harmful backlinks that could negatively impact your SEO.

6. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

Why This Metric Is Important

CTR measures the percentage of users who click on your site after seeing it in search results. It's an indicator of how compelling your meta titles and descriptions are to your target audience.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• For E-commerce:
  • Good: CTRs around 2% to 3% for competitive keywords.
  • Bad: CTRs below 1%, indicating that listings aren't enticing enough.
• For SaaS and Consumer Products:
  • Good: CTRs between 3% to 5%, as users are often seeking specific solutions or applications.
  • Bad: CTRs below 2%, suggesting a need to improve meta tags.

How to Track and Improve

Monitor CTR to ensure your search snippets are effective.

• Tracking: Use Google Search Console and go to Performance > Search Results to view CTR data for queries and pages.
• Improving:
  • Optimize Meta Titles and Descriptions: Include target keywords and craft compelling messages that address user intent.
  • Use Rich Snippets: Implement schema markup for product ratings (e-commerce) or app information (consumer products) to enhance your search listings.
  • A/B Testing: Experiment with different meta tag variations to see which ones improve CTR.

7. Impressions

Why This Metric Is Important

Impressions indicate how often your site appears in search results. They help you assess your visibility and the reach of your SEO efforts, especially when launching new content or targeting new keywords.

What Is Considered Good and Bad

• Good: An increasing trend in impressions, showing expanded visibility for relevant queries.
• Bad: A decreasing trend, potentially due to loss of rankings or issues with content relevance.

How to Track and Improve

Keep track of your impressions to gauge overall visibility.

• Tracking: In Google Search Console, under Performance > Search Results, view the total impressions your site receives.
• Improving:
  • Content Expansion: Publish new content targeting additional keywords relevant to your industry.
  • Update Existing Content: Refresh older posts to maintain their relevance and rankings.
  • Optimize for Long-Tail Keywords: These often have lower competition and can increase impressions.

Conclusion

Focusing on these seven key metrics has been instrumental in validating and enhancing SEO strategies across different industries. By understanding the specific benchmarks and challenges within e-commerce, SaaS, and consumer products, you can tailor your approach for maximum impact. Remember, SEO is a continuous process of measurement, analysis, and optimization. By concentrating on what truly drives results in your industry, you can make significant strides in your website's performance.

Ready to elevate your SEO game? Start by focusing on these metrics and customize your strategy to fit your industry's unique needs.

For more professional insights and tailored SEO tips, subscribe to our newsletter or follow us on social media. Try RankAI now!